This transfer window has been a bit of a rollercoaster, and I’m still not entirely sure how I feel about it. It’s clear that Graham Potter is trying to put his own stamp on the team, but whether the owners have truly backed him enough is up for debate. On one hand, we’ve brought in a fair few players, but on the other, our squad depth still isn’t where it should be. If Potter is going to stay and really build something, he needed proper backing, and while he’s had some, I can’t help but feel they could’ve done more to give him the tools he needs.
What’s obvious is that Potter wants to take us in a new direction. It feels like we’ve moved away from Moyes’ more experienced, hard-working core and gone for younger, more technical players who fit a different style. I can see what he’s trying to do — players like Soungoutou Magassa and Mateus Fernandes are clearly meant to bring energy and athleticism into midfield, while El Hadji Malick Diouf adds something new down the left. Mads Hermansen coming in as our long-term goalkeeper is another sign of the rebuild. But at the same time, I’ll be honest: I haven’t heard of a few of these signings before this summer, and that always leaves me a little unsure of what we’re actually getting.
Financial Savvy: The Kudus Sale and Free Transfers
Financially, we’ve been smart. Selling Mohammed Kudus to Spurs for £55 million is huge business just a shame it was to them. The move didn’t really bother me (other than selling to Spurs) because, truthfully, I thought he was pretty underwhelming last season. For all the hype, he didn’t deliver enough, so cashing in made sense. What matters more is what we did with that money, and I think we’ve reinvested fairly well without going over the top. We’ve tried to balance big signings with clever free transfers like Kyle Walker-Peters and Callum Wilson, and that’s not necessarily a bad thing if they hit the ground running.
Speaking of Wilson, I have to laugh at myself because when we signed him, I really wasn’t having it. I thought it was a cheap, short-term option, and after everything he’s said about West Ham in the past, it didn’t sit right with me at all. But after the weekend, I hate to admit I’m starting to like him. He looks sharp, he knows where the goal is, and if he keeps performing, I’ll happily eat my words. Kyle Walker-Peters is another signing I can get behind. On a free, it’s solid business, and he brings experience and versatility. That said, I’m still slightly unsure about us bringing in multiple players from Southampton given they’ve just been relegated. I get that Potter sees potential in them, but there’s always a risk in signing too many from a side that struggled so much last season. Hopefully Fernandes and the others prove me wrong.
The Emotional Cost: Emerson and Club Legends
One move I am really happy about, though, is that we’ve kept hold of Lucas Paquetá. With all the speculation around him, I was half expecting him to leave, and losing him on top of Kudus would’ve been a disaster. He’s a special player — the kind we need if we want to compete higher up the table — and I think keeping him shows there’s at least some ambition to build around our best talent rather than cashing in.
On the flip side, losing Emerson genuinely hurts. He’s been one of my favourite players, and the way he’s been pushed out doesn’t sit right with me at all. It feels like he wasn’t given a fair chance to fight for his place, and now he’s off to Marseille when I really thought he could’ve been part of Potter’s plans. That one stings.
Then there’s the bigger picture — the sheer number of departures this summer. Michail Antonio, Lukasz Fabianski, Vladimir Coufal, Aaron Cresswell, Kurt Zouma… players who’ve been around for years and played such a huge part in our identity have all gone. That’s a lot of leadership and experience to lose in one window. I understand that Potter wants to refresh the squad, but you can’t underestimate how important those personalities were in the dressing room. It’s going to take time for the new players to settle and for new leaders to step up.
Patience is Key: The Long-Term Vision
Mads Hermansen is another player I feel needs more patience from fans. He’s young, talented, and clearly signed to be our long-term number one, but he’s been thrown straight into the deep end and people are already on his back after a couple of rough games. He needs time to adapt, and I genuinely believe he’ll prove himself if we give him the chance.
Overall, I think this window has been ambitious, but it comes with plenty of risk. We’ve brought in players who fit Potter’s style and finally addressed areas we’ve needed to strengthen – centre-back and goalkeeper especially – but at the same time, we’ve lost a lot of experience, and we’re relying on several signings to hit the ground running. With so many new faces and a completely different approach, it’s going to take time for everything to click. I wouldn’t call it the perfect window, but I also don’t think it’s been a disaster. There’s a clear plan here, even if it’s one that feels uncomfortable right now. We’ve said goodbye to players who’ve defined the club in recent years, taken a gamble on youth and potential, and reshaped the core of the squad. Whether it pays off, only time will tell, but at least it feels like we’re trying to build something rather than just patch holes. If the owners are serious about backing Potter, though, they need to keep supporting him beyond this summer. The squad is thinner than it should be, and we’re only one or two injuries away from problems in key areas. I want to believe in the process, but he needs the tools to make it work. For now, I’m staying hopeful, if slightly nervous, about what’s ahead. It might not be smooth sailing, but there’s a sense that something is changing — and I just hope we’re on the right side of it.
Be the first to comment