
Baroness Brady has left the building and her “world-class” team has fallen through the Premier League trapdoor. Following her is going to be a tough assignment for any new CEO, and that’s obviously not intended as a compliment to Karren. While many hope that Brady’s stage(d) exit pre-empts that of her long-term employer, I remain unconvinced that a change of ownership would bring the required reset. That’s not a vote of confidence in Sullivan, merely an acceptance that many fan gripes – at the London Stadium and further afield – are symptomatic of modern football and commercialism. Still, whatever else this summer brings, there will be a reset. Player changes will be wholesale. Karim Virani was only appointed as interim CEO, although early whisperings about the man who previously spent five years leading our digital, marketing and commercial operations have been favourable. Change may be inevitable in all walks of life but what we have here is churn: reset after reset after reset. And that spells doom for any business. Yes, I just called West Ham United a business. Much as I might rail against it, there’s no point denying that that’s what professional sports teams are today, and the likes of Bournemouth, Brentford and Brighton are prospering because they have good business plans.
Creating a unique selling point with a community ethos
The corporate sphere is awash with mission statements and values, most of them given lip service when it is the bottom line that matters above all else. But what I would like most from this reset is for West Ham to forge a strong identity and to explicitly define what “the West Ham Way” is. This was alluded to in the statement that followed relegation: “West Ham United is a football club whose unique identity is defined not by success or failure on the pitch, but by the values and traditions of our roots in east London, and by the spirit of the people who have Claret and Blue in their hearts.” Nice sentiments, but easy to ride roughshod over, as evidenced by various debacles around the stadium and concessions. So would it be asking too much for this vague notion of identity to be developed into an iron-clad constitution or manifesto that guides all future decision making? It would certainly be unique in the English game, but therein lies opportunity, and that’s a word that pricks the ears of the capitalist types who run football clubs. A UK club with strong, clear and – dare I say it?! – anti-capitalist values would be a unique selling point.
Looking abroad and down the pyramid for radical blueprints
The closest to what I’m thinking can be found lower down the English football league. For example, Forest Green Rovers attract a fair amount of goodwill (notwithstanding the vegan refreshments) thanks to an eco-friendly agenda, although this is tied to the values of its green industrialist owner Dale Vince and would be fortunate to survive his selling up. Even further down the pyramid, Dulwich Hamlet and Clapton Community FC have made virtues of a community ethos that bucks the national trend. Elsewhere in Europe, FC St Pauli attract the right type of tourists, with continental football fans flocking to Hamburg because the club’s progressive values stand out even in the democracy of Germany’s fan-ownership model. And at the top of the tree sit Barcelona, with a club culture built on Catalan identity and attacking verve, although no longer immune to money issues. What exactly the West Ham Way would look like is up for debate, as it has been for decades. But wouldn’t it be nice to finally be able to answer with confidence a question that has stumped managers from Sam Allardyce to David Moyes. And wouldn’t it be nice if fans were central to the whole process. I know, I know, I’m living in la-la land to even suggest such a utopian concept amid the money-hungry dystopia of modern football. But really, the only thing standing in the way is the will of ownership.
Hindsight and the harsh lessons of ripped up plans
Looking back at a piece I wrote at the start of the season on the potential importance of Graham Potter in shaping Sullivan’s legacy, I opined that ‘what’s obvious is that the club can’t afford to keep ripping up plans and starting again. We’re stuck with the stadium so we’re crying out for a manager who can finally realise the Olympic legacy and make good on the board’s sales pitch.’ Oh well. Going further back, the final entry of my first book, Fortune’s Always Hiding: From Stratford to Seville, was titled ‘Architects of Our Own Downfall’ and lamented certain GSB failings in the wake of the Europa League semi-final defeat to Eintracht Frankfurt, while also arguing that ‘if you compare where we are now with where we were when they took over, it would be hard to conclude that they’ve done a bad job.’ Er, in the harsh glare of hindsight, less said about that one the better. Idealistic it may be to wish for a principled club culture with community rather than commercialism at its heart, transparently written down in a constitution that all custodians are obliged to adhere to. But it’s not impossible. So I’ll cross my fingers and hope that this cry for improved governance proves third time lucky!
Be the first to comment