In 107 years as members of the Football League, we have been relegated on only seven occasions. During that time we have never played outside of the top two tiers – a feat achieved by only eight other clubs. Our longest spell outside of the top flight is 26 years (1932-1958) and we have bounced straight back after one season on two occasions (1993 and 2012). At all other times we have never been absent for more than three years. This latest edition to the roll call of failure should therefore be seen in proper context.
The Realities and Financial Cost of Drop
Everyone knew it was coming, it felt like a car crash in slow motion. Responsibility must ultimately rest with the players, who simply failed to do their job. A moderate squad maybe, but no worse than Fulham, Leeds or Crystal Palace. More importantly one that was capable of grinding out the right results. They just didn’t respond for huge swathes of the season. The financial cost of relegation from the Premier League is well documented. It will cost the club in the region of £100 million and follows an operating loss of £104 million announced in May 2025. One silver lining is a clause in the club’s 99 year lease that means they pay the Greater London Authority half their annual rent. A saving of £2.2 million is always welcome but would barely be enough to cover one player’s annual salary.
The Retain and Transfer Era of 1932
But looking back, how has the club managed in previous post relegation seasons? When we were first relegated in 1931/32, clubs were largely self-regulating where players were concerned. They had no real control over their careers and could leave only if the club allowed them. The ‘retain and transfer’ system had been in place since 1893 and would last for another 70 years. There was a maximum wage in force where players could earn no more than £8 per week which reduced to £6 during the summer. Players would often take additional jobs to make ends meet. For example, legendary Preston and England striker Tom Finney was a plumber during any financial lean spells. With a maximum wage players could generally earn no more elsewhere. There were inducements and nefarious under the table transactions, but for most players there was little point in forcing the issue. As a result, we began the 1932/33 season with an intact squad. England internationals Vic Watson, Jimmy Ruffell and Jim Barrett were still present. Exciting young prospects like Len Goulden and John Morton were also breaking through. Unfortunately it became the mother of all nightmares as we avoided relegation to the third tier on goal average.
Brooking, Bonds, and the Golden Era Bounce Back (1978–1981)
It’s difficult to imagine how we could have been relegated in 1977/78. Of course, no team is ever too good to go down. But we had, in all truth, been ‘cruising for a bruising’, having posted only one top 10 finish in the previous eight seasons. Nevertheless, we had a fine squad that included Trevor Brooking, Billy Bonds, Frank Lampard, Alan Devonshire and the evergreen ‘Pop’ Robson. The excellent David Cross had also been signed to strengthen the attack. Add to this the emerging young talents like Alvin Martin and Geoff Pike, and it appeared to be a formidable lineup. Fans might have feared the worst, but the aforementioned players were all retained and had a key role in the promotion campaigns that followed. There were several reasons for such a contented group. It was an era when players generally displayed more loyalty to their clubs. There were no agents to sow the seeds of discontent or undermine existing contracts. There was less of a gap between the top two tiers. So the quality of football played was comparable and the distinction largely cosmetic. As a result there was no negative impact on a player’s career, especially where England was concerned. In three years out of the top flight (1978-1981) a number of Hammers players won full England caps or received a call-up. Trevor Brooking won 20 of his 47 caps during this period, whilst Alan Devonshire made his England debut as a substitute against Northern Ireland. Frank Lampard won his second cap against Australia and Billy Bonds was called up on several occasions. However, Ron Greenwood was manager of England which undoubtedly strengthened their claims. But modern England managers would never consider players outside the Premier or top European leagues.
Cup Glory and the Record Title Triumph
In the 1978/79 season, we fell short of promotion and finished a disappointing fifth. The only significant departures were Pop Robson, who returned to his native North East, and Alan Curbishley, who transferred to Birmingham following an alleged fallout with John Lyall. Mervyn Day and Tommy Taylor also left but there were fine replacements in position. Alvin Martin was already at the club, and most tellingly Phil Parkes was signed from QPR. A fee of £565,000 made him the world’s most expensive goalkeeper but it would be money well spent. England international Stuart Pearson was signed from Manchester United, and mercurial winger Jimmy Neighbour joined from Norwich. The 1979/80 season was another born of frustration as we finished seventh, six points off promotion. It did, however, witness the blossoming talent of Paul Allen, another product of the club’s academy programme. Future penalty king Ray Stewart was also signed from Dundee United for £440,000. There was the consolation of a memorable FA Cup Final win over Arsenal. We became the last second tier side to win the FA Cup but our league form didn’t stand any real comparison. The following season (1980/81) saw a unique ‘double’ as we won promotion and reached the League Cup Final. The first team squad remained intact and saw the addition of the highly rated striker Paul Goddard. He was signed from QPR for £800,000 and would form a highly effective partnership with David Cross. It became a victory roll for us as we won the title by a clear 13 points from Notts County in second place. We had a goal difference of +50 and lost only four league games all season. Cross and Goddard plundered 60 goals between them as we also reached the quarter finals of the European Cup Winners Cup.
The End of Lyall and the Early Nineties Rollercoaster
The Championship title marked the beginning of an eight year spell in the top flight. The highlight was a third place finish in 1985/86, the season we all dared to dream of winning the ‘big one’. By 1989, a mini golden era was about to end. Trevor Brooking and Billy Bonds had retired; Frank Lampard left to finish his career at Southend and Tony Cottee was sold to Everton. Relegation in 1988/89 wasn’t the biggest surprise in a wretched season. It was the sacking of manager John Lyall that raised most eyebrows. Many saw it as an act of betrayal and raged at the treatment of one of the club’s finest servants. In retrospect Lyall had a great run and became a club icon. But after 15 years as manager it was time for a change. Lou Macari was appointed manager after guiding Swindon to promotion in successive seasons. The eve of the 1989/90 season saw plenty of movement in the playing staff. Paul Ince was always likely to move but his departure was hastened by relegation. Ince eventually signed for Manchester United in September 1989 but incurred the wrath of fans when he posed in a United shirt before the transfer was complete. Meanwhile, winger Mark Ward had long been agitating for a move. His transfer to Manchester City saw Ian Bishop and Trevor Morley sign for us in a sound piece of business. Aside from the City pair, Ludek Miklosko and Martin Allen were also signed during Macari’s tenure at the club. The campaign was generally disappointing as we finished 7th. We also suffered the ignominy of defeat against 4th Division Torquay in the FA Cup. Macari resigned in February 1990 following allegations whilst at Swindon. His last game in charge was a shattering 6-0 defeat in the first leg of the League Cup semi-final against Oldham. Billy Bonds took over and sprinkled some much needed inspiration. The 1990/91 season was greeted with a degree of hope and some expectation as we were tipped for promotion. And so it came to pass, as we were promoted but pipped for the title by Oldham Athletic. Overall, it was a comfortable promotion season complemented by a run to the FA Cup semi-final. The memory of Tony Gale being sent off against Nottingham Forest lingers like a bad taste in the mouth. It denied us an FA Cup Final between West Ham and Spurs – the closest it’s ever come to happening.
Missing the Premier League Launch and the 2000s Play-Offs
The final season of the old First Division (1991/92) was an unmitigated failure for the club became embroiled in the bond fiasco and relegated for the second time in four years. We seemed ill-equipped for life in the top flight. Billy Bonds’ war chest was limited and only able to sign Mitchell Thomas, Kenny Brown and Mike Small. It was a season to forget as we finished bottom winning only nine league games and scoring a pitiful 37 goals. It was perhaps classic West Ham contriving to miss the inaugural season of the Premier League (1992/93). However, the nucleus of the squad that won promotion in 1991 was still in place. The partnership between Clive Allen and Trevor Morley produced 34 league goals between them. We returned to the top flight in 1993 and stayed there for 10 years. It saw the eventful tenure of Harry Redknapp and the club’s highest ever finish in the Premier League (5th in 1998/99). The era also witnessed the emergence of West Ham’s golden generation and the re-building of Upton Park. Whilst Glenn Roeder guided the club to a 7th place finish in 2001 his health was deteriorating. Trevor Brooking took over as caretaker manager but couldn’t prevent relegation descending once again in 2002/03. The fact that we were relegated with a record number of points (42), sixteen points ahead of West Brom in nineteenth place and only two points behind Bolton was cold comfort. By now there was an extensive conveyor belt of players coming and going. The age of the ‘hired gun’ was upon us but the quality was sometimes dubious. In the aftermath Joe Cole, Paolo Di Canio, Frederic Kanoute and Lee Boweyer all left the club. However, Marlon Harewood, Matt Etherington and Nigel Reo-Coker were among the promising signings for the new campaign. There were problems off the pitch as Glenn Roeder was ultimately dismissed and replaced by Trevor Brooking again in a caretaking role. Alan Pardew was appointed as manager in October 2003. We were agonisingly close, finishing 4th and losing to Crystal Palace in the play-off final. Progress was incremental as the following season (2004/05) proved to be momentous. Teddy Sheringham and Sergei Rebrov were signed with varying degrees of success. We just squeezed into the play-offs in 6th place. A 2-2 draw against Ipswich in away leg of the semi-final left nerves jangling for the return. A double from the underrated Bobby Zamora sealed a second consecutive play-off final. It was Zamora again as he scored the winner against Preston in football’s richest game.
Allardyce and the Most Recent Return
Fast forward to the 2010/11 season and the appointment of Avram Grant as manager. A miserable campaign was enlivened by a run to the League Cup semi-final but could not disguise a bottom place finish. Grant was followed by the derided but effective Sam Allardyce. The most high profile departure was striker Demba Ba who left for Newcastle. Allardyce brought in Kevin Nolan as captain for a highly productive spell. Matt Taylor, Joey O’Brien and Abdouaye Faye were also signed to strengthen the squad. We were just pipped to an automatic promotion spot by Southampton. Cardiff were swept aside in the play-off semi-final 5-0 on aggregate to set up the final against Blackpool. Goals from Carlton Cole and Ricardo Vaz Te sent us back to the top flight. The old maxim of the season being a marathon not a sprint is still highly appropriate. Strap yourselves in people because it will be a bumpy ride.
Be the first to comment